Fat in a Jar Isn’t Skincare Innovation

By Paul Teasdale — The Unfiltered Formulator

One side sells nostalgia. The other builds solutions.

It had to be said.

Beef tallow is trending. Again. 🙄

Wrapped in aesthetic packaging. Pushed with ancestral narratives.

Sold as some kind of skincare revolution.

Let me be clear. It’s not.

It’s just fat in a jar.

And if you think that’s formulation, we’ve got a bigger problem than just bad marketing.

Simplicity Isn’t the Same as Sophistication

Consumers are burned out.

They’re overwhelmed by long INCI lists, afraid of any ingredient they can’t pronounce, and clinging to anything that feels “clean.”

So tallow feels safe. Natural. Pure.

And on the surface, that makes sense.

But under the hood? There’s nothing innovative here. No delivery system. No functional actives. No evidence-based strategy.

Just occlusion. Just fat.

If that’s all you think skin needs, you’re not formulating. You’re guessing.

Simplicity without science isn’t elegance. It’s empty.

The “Toxin-Free” Lie

Let’s be honest.

Most of these brands aren’t selling skincare. They’re selling fear.

Fear of “toxins.”

Fear of “chemicals.”

Fear of anything that sounds remotely scientific.

The result?

• No preservatives.

• No emulsifiers.

• No pH adjustments.

• No safety testing.

And no understanding of what real product stability or microbiological control actually means.

If you’re putting an unpreserved, oil-based product in a jar and telling people it’s safer than a dermatologist-backed moisturiser, you’re not just misinformed — you’re irresponsible.

Fear-based marketing might sell — but mold doesn’t care about vibes.

Let’s Talk Science

Tallow is biologically compatible with human skin. That’s true.

It contains fatty acids that can support the lipid layer. Also true.

It’s occlusive and can feel nourishing. Sure.

But let’s zoom out.

Modern moisturisers combine:

• Humectants that draw moisture into the skin

• Emollients that improve texture and softness

• Actives that support barrier repair, inflammation control, and elasticity

• Preservation systems that protect the product and the user

• Delivery mechanisms that enhance penetration and bioavailability

You’re not getting that in beef fat.

You’re getting nostalgia with a side of oil slick.

Real moisturisers balance function, feel, and safety. That takes more than just fat.

The Ethical Side No One Talks About

Tallow isn’t a cute, earthy, upcycled material. It’s animal fat.

And in an industry pushing hard into biotech, cruelty-free, and sustainability, that matters.

We have lab-grown lipids now. Fermented actives. Biocompatible ingredients engineered for precision.

We’re not short on options. We’re short on integrity.

If you’re going to use animal-derived materials, fine. Just be honest about it. And back it up with real data not a rustic font and a promise that your ancestors did it first.

From farm to fermentation — the future of skincare isn’t rustic, it’s refined.

Formulation Without Testing Isn’t Minimalist. It’s Reckless.

You want a stripped-back product? Great. But where’s the:

• Challenge testing?

• Micro stability?

• Long-term oxidation data?

• Skin compatibility studies?

• SPF claims validated by labs, not sunlight and vibes?

If the answer is “we don’t need that because it’s natural,” then you don’t understand how this industry works. Or how skin works.

If you skip the testing, you’re not minimal — you’re irresponsible.

The Bar Is Higher Than This

If your brand is pushing beef tallow like it’s revolutionary, I’m not here to cancel you.

I’m here to challenge you.

Because skincare deserves more than a trend.

Consumers deserve more than a vibe.

And the industry deserves more than regression dressed up as innovation.

Let’s move forward. Not backwards.

Paul Teasdale

Cosmetic Chemist. Strategic Partner. Unfiltered Voice of Formulation.

Follow The Unfiltered Formulator on Instagram